Nova’s "The Deadliest Plane Crash" (no, not the NYC one)

Nova’s latest episode, “The Deadliest Plane Crash,” focuses on the collision of two 747 jumbo jets on the island of Tenerife in 1977. Due to a myriad of factors, most notable and most importantly grossly negligent pilot error (without which there would have been no accident) a KLM jet ran into a Pan Am jet while both were on the runway in heavy fog. The accident killed nearly 600 people and has been the single deadliest aviation accident in history (provided that one doesn’t consider 9/11 an aviation accident).

In true Nova style, the show meticulously recreates the events and sets the scene wonderfully. The show is full of actor’s playing out the events that occurred on Tenerife on March 27th of that year. These recreations are interspersed with interviews of people that were on hand and computer recreations.

The story is compelling, at least initially, but the nearly hour long runtime of the show slowly has the power of the message seep out. While the confluence of factors that took place in order to set the stage for the plane crash are interesting, in the end it really all just boils down to the captain of one plane making a horrific mistake: he failed to get clearance for takeoff. All the other factors aside that put two planes on the same runway at the same time, had the pilot bothered to try and get clearance for takeoff the accident never would have occurred.

The episode does attempt to go into the pilot’s mentality, and the atmosphere in the cockpit at the time, but by the time it explores this, it seems a case of too little too late. The show fails to delve deep enough into the psychology of the pilot, and some of the suppositions made by the experts come off sounding foolish (whether they are accurate I cannot attest to, just that they sound foolish).

“The Deadliest Plane Crash” closes out the episode by bringing the audience to the modern day and discussing the likelihood of such an event occurring again. The experts indicate that it is all too likely, and that while some advancements and technologies exist that could prevent such crashes in the future, they are not installed at enough airports and nothing is being done to rectify this situation.

The problem with the show is not that the subject matter isn’t interesting, it very much is. It’s also not necessarily that it’s presented in a bad way; this is the way that Nova presents everything and it has certainly proven hugely successful. The problem is simply that some more judicious editing and another look at the pacing of the episode is required in order to fully captivate viewers and educate them about the history of the incident and the danger of fewer incidents. The episode is by no means “bad” either. It is informative and interesting, just overly long and a little too leisurely paced.

Nova – “The Deadliest Plane Crash” airs on PBS, Tuesday October 17th at 8PM ET/PT

Categories: Uncategorized


2 replies

  1. Hello Josh,

    Your constructive criticism tells more about you than any issues with the show. This is a detailed analysis of the events that lead to the crash. To thoroughly examine the details, the pace must slow down. If you want a faster pace, watch a James Bond movie. Nothing is more annoying than a review that criticizes just to be critical. I guess it makes you feel superior to the cutting edge minds that create documentaries like this for a living at PBS. You would have served yourself better to discuss why the pace slows when the details are examined rather than opposing the very nature of a documentary.
    Best of luck in your future reviews,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s